General Project Thread & Feedback

Draw a better Sonic. Go on, I dare you.

Vincent, does Sonic have more shades than the 'UBER' ones we saw you making a while ago? The screenshots show a more airbrushed Sonic, which I like a lot.

 

Wow. Yeah. Go review the original art archives and then tell us that.

 

I think that the art, levels, etc. all look beautiful. Sonic looks pretty damn good, probably the best sonic I've seen in a game.

Yup, everything looks gorgeous and I think some people are just mad because it wasn't the alpha release. Once it comes out all will be forgotten and they will say "HOLY SHIT! AWESOME GAME!!!!!"

 

Would you really want me to just dump a ton in one post? :v:

 

Sonic Looks Much Nicer When He's Remade By His Fans (Kotaku)

Welcome to sonic 4 bitchfest '11.

 

Well, some comments are okay, like "GameBuddy - Voices? I got 'em" or whoever that is. I do agree with one person and would love to have that logo on a black t-shirt. That'll be bitching.

I'd hate to see Destructoid's approach to this...XD

 

Perhaps it's because art has never been something that I have a keen eye for, but I think the game looks brilliant. Maybe I'm missing something, but I like what I'm seeing so far.

 

Yes, the art is more than 10x better now than when we last saw it.

And thank you for not keeping that old glossy egg-ship. Dunno who made it, but it didn't look metallic.

 

...Thank you for your criticsm, but it looked much more metallic like than this glossy-like thing.

"Dunno who made it", asshole.

 

Sorry. I wasn't thinking then. I shouldn't have said anything.
I didn't actually mean it as offensively as that.

 

Are you trying to stir up trouble?

On topic: It sucks that the alpha got delayed but in the end there is nothing we can do to change it. From what I saw it looks nice, hopefully it will play as nicely as it looks.

 

Sorry taken. don't worry. Its ok, I know it wasnt chromish enough...
But that wasnt my goal, since the original one isnt chrome-coated.

Nope.

 

What have we learned from Sega, everyone?

"Rushing = bad."

Yes, there's frustration that it's been two years since the proof of concept and it's only just nearing a first Alpha release. There's also frustration in how the countdown was handled.

If you like what you see, cool. I'm sure that'll give the team a nice boost in confidence, and despite some rather obnoxious pessimism within these boards and this topic, reaction from the wider web has been rather positive.

If you don't, that's cool too. The community part here is where you talk about what you don't like and explain why without insulting the team. As CK said, contributions are more than welcome still if you wish to do so, but the team expects you to follow the guidelines for submission. Understandable since the game should at least have some uniformity in look, not a mish-mash that actually WILL make it look like a shoddy flash game.

Perhaps things will move at a more brisk pace now. Perhaps not. The only thing that should be done is to continue being patient.

A nugget of joy.

 

concerning Canned Karma's post addressing the openness of the project <http://forums.sonicretro.org/index.php?s=&showtopic=10111&view=findpost&p=426208>, this means that the community should suggest and create art/concepts, etc., but just wait to see if it's accepted into the game without expecting a concrete "yes" or "no" after a certain period of time?... I'm not trying to come off as facetious; that's just how it sounds and how it seems to have been as far, for the most part.

 

I'm under the impression that we, as community members, can submit concepts and even actual art, but the staff will take it and improve it until it is up to S2HD art standards and fits the chosen art style properly.

I have no problem with this. As a matter of fact, I actually like the concept of the closed community project. It keeps the bitching to a minimum. However, I do agree with many others in that it should be less closed than it is now. I mean, we really have no idea what you guys are up to. Personally, when the change was first made, it made me feel like I wasn't welcome to work on the project anymore. The announcement that outlined the changes when the project went "closed community" said we were still welcome, but actions speak louder than words and all that.

Just as an idea, a read-only forum for non-staff members could be easily added to show us what's happening, at least. That would eliminate the bickering, and we wouldn't feel so alienated. Actually, why have we been kept completely in the dark with the progress of the staff's art? Have you folks just wanted to surprise everyone with something really impressive at each release? I mean, if that's the case, then I suppose my idea isn't worth much, as little as I like that school of though.

However, I did not say how much I enjoyed the game footage so far with my last post. Excellent job, S2HD staff, it looks great! My complaining aside, you folks get good results.

 

I'd like this. Depending on how often we'd get updates. But, I'm pretty satisfied right now, and the alpha release will be my icing.

 

I had no idea there was a countdown at all...or anything. I just strolled in here, saw talk of a trailer and promptly watched said trailer.

And I liked it. Looked good. Loved the remix of the special stage theme. Good stuff, looking forward to seeing more!

 

How about something akin to Devroom on Capcom-Unity?

With Legends 3, a member of the game staff usually does a report about what's going on in the form of a weekly blog post. She also teases upcoming opportunities for fans to get involved.

I don't see this as a bad idea, now that Karma can create front page posts.