Tails Advance

sounds good! I used to do a bit of that! it was really fun!

if there is anything you need help with then just ask.

 

If the gameplay matches the presentation then it's a sure winner!

 

-3 points for using Tails' sprite from Sonic Advance.
-5 points for using Sonic Advance style graphics.
2 points for the emerald hill graphics.
-2 points for the grass shadow not matching the advance grass
-4 points for the water in the background looking like... I have no idea but not water.

Overview:
Not much have been done except the emerald hill edit of Leaf Forest which I think is okay. I don't like mixing original Sonic with Advance style graphics though.


That's my review of what you have done so far. So the only thing that can increase your score is the actual engine.

 

I did work on Sonic Advance myself. I spend last summer porting 4 levels, I got less replies than this thread

I know what's in and not, and Sonic Advance has never been in.

I know you have made hard work to it. This is just scored for the screenshots you were showing, not for the game play. If Sonic Advance had been better, more people would like your work, but that isn't the case. You are using graphics and layouts from a game no one wants to talk about here. I'm happy to give you score. Other people don't even care.

I love Leaf Forest! It's the greatest Sonic Advance level. I have spent so much time even covering up details over it here:
http://shit.sclassic.net/index.php/Leaf_Forest

Mixing it with original Sonic such as "emerald hill" makes it kinda bad. It doesn't fit. It isn't the same design. But of course Leaf Forest was more of a Emerald Hill clone than any other Sonic Advance level.

 

I like it. I personally like the graphics of the Advance series, but the gameplay ruined it. We've seen the old games enough and I think it's refreshing to see something like this. Sonic games don't usually have the best art ever, what makes the games great is the gameplay. Based on what I've seen, it's got potential. Show us a bit of the gameplay.
This community is oldschool biased, new = bad. The idea could work, but unfortunatly I doubt you'll get the positive response here.

 

Not true, really. I have closely studied the art of the older Sonic games. If you compare it to other genesis games, you can really see the difference.

No, not true at all. I don't like the newer Sonic games because they are simply not good. I tried to like them, I really did.

I still enjoy the new Mario games, now why is that? It's because they were made very good. Same with the new Zelda games.



Now, on topic. This game looks like it may be good. You have done a great job mimicking the "Advance" style art.