The Sonic the Hedgehog Continuity Thread of Love and Timelines

deleted

 

This has come up before. Sonic Drift 2 has an Ice Cap track, so that's not the case.

 

Or just maybe there's another Ice Cap in West Side Island. There's a Hidden Palace after all.

 

deleted

 

You said Sonic Drift 2 "clearly" takes place on West Side Island. It doesn't "clearly" take place on West Side Island if it has a Sonic 3 zone in it. If you have to make up a reason why Ice Cap isn't Ice Cap then no, it isn't "clear" that the entire game takes place on West Side Island.

This thread isn't for presenting fan theory as fact, that leads to misinformation and confusion. There's another thread for headcanons.

 

It's like some wikia claiming that Studiopolis is on West Side Island because Chemical Plant leads to it, even though we don't know if anything was real or illusion.

 

deleted

 

Indeed, and Iron Ruin is implied to be the remnants of Scrap Brain Zone, from the outline.

So Sonic Drift 2 implicitly takes place on all three islands of the mainlines, but appears to mostly take place on Westside Island, since most of the tracks are recognisably from there.

If we're going off Taxman's development stream, then apparently it did all actually happen if I recall correctly.

 

I checked out the JP text and it says 見知らぬ人 which means “someone you don’t recognize.” Trying to make these kinds of inferences off a translation isn’t a good idea.

Edit: Typed the wrong kana.

 

That's a stretch as well.

 

I don't see the resemblance.

 

Then you may want to edit Iron Ruins' wiki entry, since it notes the same thing.

It's the black domed buildings with the red windows, and the distant jagged pylons that make people think they're related.

 

The architecture is completely different. They just have a similar silhouette effect.

 

I find fan wikis in general lack proper citation standards. People tend to post whatever subjective interpretation they want. There is a vague similarity between the silhouettes but not to the extent that I would mention it on the wiki page unless there was an official source stating there's a connection.

 

Yeah, recently I've been trying to add more citations to wikis in general. I think every wiki needs to improve their citations standards.

 

I thought that the only mystery that surrounds Sonic CD is R2, and the early versions of the special stage. BUT today a friend showed me this:

And we had an argument about when exactly the Sonic CD events take place.
According to our wiki- between Sonic 1 and 2, but according to this data my friend thinks that it happens... after 3?

 

The official canon, as of Sonic Origins, is that CD is set between Sonic 1 and 2.

 

Anyway https://prong-earwig-daa.notion.sit...timeline-2-0-1f5d6cbb5e31492daaee4f238fbfb572

 

I also thought about Mecha Sonic and Metal Sonic.
In my opinion the evolution goes like: Mecha from Sonic 2 –> Mecha from Sonic & Knuckles, while Metal is a separate version.
It seems Ohshima-san views it in a different way: Mecha from Sonic 2 –> Metal from Sonic CD.
—————
When I first saw Metal Sonic in Heroes, my first thought was: "It's that robot from S&K".

Sonic looks here like on Heroes cover.

The Official Cookbook. Pretty awesome, huh? Who needs an artbook with concept art for Sonic 3, CD – with all that Ice Cap, Temple in the Sky, Dubious Depths / Ridicule Root stuff?
We want to know how to cook chili dogs!
...right?