The S Factor: Sonia and Silver

It's not from the game, it's from a show (a cartoon more precisely).

 

Very nice hack, I love playing as Scourge the Hedgehog (Since he has Sonic's gameplay style), and I like the music, nice job indeed, I like A.N.N's theme, the three act White Blaster tunes (Nice use of Deep Core, I like Act 3's BGM the most), the hip hop/rap version of the Sonic 1 Boss theme, and Arid Temple Act 1's BGM as well.

As for the levels, I like the new layouts, and the new art (Since Spectra Valley and Arid Temple use the art from Sonic One (Jayextee's old canceled hack of Sonic 1)).

Overall, nice work, I can't wait to see more progress on this hack soon.

Some of the songs are from Totally Spies (Aquaslash's favorite show, and Chaotic Street's BGM is from Totally Spies), most of the songs are from other Sonic games, and one of the Songs are from Sonic Underground.

 

Glad to see someone liking what little I contributed, although Aquaslash deserves kudos for 'finishing off' Spectra Valley's art somewhat... anyone who's ragequit rather than do that FUCKING s-tube or loop-the-loop will know why I stopped right there

 

Thanks. ^^

 

I actually like the act 3 BGM the most because it doesn't have the annoying ring-like instrument :P

 

Hm, I coulda sworn Arid-something, Act 3 was pretty much covering Arid Sands from Sonic Unleashed at at least one point.

 

huh, I think you forgot to mention teh Metal Sonic theme, unless I fail at reading?

 

Looks just like Metal Sonic, 'cept the white stripe on the forehead-to-middle-spine.

Also, a glitch I encountered, dunno if it'd been addressed before, on Genesis Plus, Wii-Port.

White Blaster, Marble-Garden-Zone-Boss-copy. When in Super Form. the game stops, repeating the same five or so miliseconds of sound. Emulator-menu still accessable, though.

 

Great hack! I was excited to see a release for it (Even if it is a Beta)

Just a few things I noticed (not necessarily complaints, just opinions)

1. Good lord, Spectra Valley is freaking hard the first time around!
2. The multi-phase boss in Spectra Valley was surprising, and very unique. (I've only seen something like that in videos for Megamix)
3. Maybe it's just me, but I could've sworn that the second zone (forgot its name already) shared the same layout as the second zone for Ollie's Sonic Ring Rush on Hacktube. <- Or, maybe that's the unedited layout of Labyrinth Zone and I need to play more Sonic 1. Disregard, cocks, you get the idea.

I haven't played any further than the second zone, as I'm gonna have to get used to the new characters ('specially Silver, who is the only one I actually play as in the game), but wow, keep it up!

 

Since I don't really use this site often for posting anymore, consider this useful when I say that was well worth the wait.

In terms of Feedback-

Loved the originality in level design, music and particulally in the bosses. I'm guessing Malevolence had a hand in there given that insanely hard Metal Knuckles fight.

I was also very impressed with the work on the sprites, as well as their movesets and how suprisingly handy they came in. And another thing- thank god you got rid of the special stages and replaced them with something a lot more suitable. Inventive, I like it.



In terms of critisicms, I'm guessing there isn't really much else I can add that you haven't been told about or know already.

Spike Bug- Although I'm guessing has been left in intentionally. For some reason, even though spikes aren't as noticable as in Sonic 1, when they are noticed here, its usually in the most inconvienient places. Chaotic Street and Ring Land being prime examples. (The Spike Bug managed to work upwards through a shield in Ring Land Act 2).

I'm guessing the game is going to feature Slowdown Shoes...

And last thing, although loved the rest of the tracks. The quirkiness of the Ring Land theme tune gets tiring very quickly. Is it not possible to just leave that section as part of an intro?



Thanks very much and look forward to seeing this finished.

 

A feature I'd very much like to see:
-Skip score calculation
-A tiny bit more difference between the Speed Boots and Slow Boots monitors (Just something small and subtle, I can't see ANY difference between them at the moment)

I made other positive feedback earlier in this topic.

 

If you know what the slow shoes monitor looks like you would stay away from it, hence removing the trickery that makes it interesting.

 

I'd like to be able to avoid obstacles by virtue of something other than rote memorization.

 

There is a difference. Hint: + - Sonic Adventure 2.  

 

My one big crit, and I feel perfectly justified in saying this...
You could stand to make the Metal Knuckles boss into more of a plausible boss fight, and into less of a violent rape involving a barbed wire covered extension.

Harsh as that may sound, the fight is insanely difficult. The fight with A.N.N is barely reasonable in terms of difficulty, but I could live with that. The Metal Knuckles fight crosses the line. Particularly during the part of the fight where he decided to make rape incarnate rain from the sky. As if hitting him to begin with wasn't enough of a pain in the ass.

E_E Seriously, there's a difference between giving players a challenge and subtly flipping them the finger.

 

I am by NO means a skilled player - I even have difficulty with Sonic 2's difficulty in general -, but after a couple of tries, Metal Knuckles actually appears to be quite beatable - it's not easy, but doable, nevertheless.

 

Yes the Metal Knukles boss can be hard if you not super. But I prefer a challenge once in awhile and I thought that boss was awsome.