Something better than a "isn't Sonic good/bad/whatever": I regularly haunt archive.org for useful wiki material. Today there was a big upload, and now I can present a digitised version of Sonic Jam Official Guide: https://retrocdn.net/File:SonicJamOfficialGuide_Book_JP.pdf (!!!) This is a fairly extensive guide book for the Sega Saturn game, Sonic Jam, and by extension, guides for Sonic 1, 2, 3 and Knuckles. Much of the foundations of the Sonic Retro wiki were based on the teachings of this book - names for things, comments from developers, weird miscellaneous facts, etc. But there wasn't a copy online, so many of the smaller details were missing (if they were even understood). And of course, without references nothing could be verified (see: the many Japanese -> English translations) - now it can. Everything in this book should be mirrored on the wiki in some form. You should volunteer etc.
I believe those scans are by own Scotty that he did a year ago, are they not? That's where people have been getting some facts like Sonic's sneezing was a spider sense etc etc. I also think he might've made a thread about it but not sure if I'm confusing it with something else he scanned.
Well if it's been lost in a sea of forum posts, that very much proves the point I keep making. The one about putting everything on the wiki. But we have a version now, and that's what counts