Left one, obviously. Just look at all that detail! The contrast is better than the right sprite, and I also like the effect you've given it. Personally, I think you'd be a fool to not use the left one. It's great to see you're still working on this; the graphics you've put into this game are simply phenomenal.
Out of the two, just like everyone else. I'm going for the left! One question about this hack, where did the Madonna signpost go? Encountering that in one of your previous builds for the first time had me in stitches.
Alright! The overwhelming majority (100% of everyone) chose the new one. That's fine with me! =P She is still there. I just never got around to putting her into that newer build.