I found the video interesting because the creator has mixed feelings on the game, so he sets it up like a "Choose Your Adventure" deal to work through his feelings about it. Neutral - The game has an interesting premise but is weighed down by how schizophrenic it feels. Shadow will go from one place to the next at complete random, and his characterization almost never makes sense (eg on the Hero routes he'll still act like a smug asshole) Dark - The game is horribly repetitive to 100% and some missions are really awful, forcing you to tediously find and kill everyone. The Sonic characters are turned into soulless puppets in order to support Shadow's freedom of choice. The bosses are braindead easy. Hero - The music is amazing. A couple of levels are cool. The game gives you the thrilling power fantasy of killing cops. Last Story - GUN being made into good guys makes SA2 feel pointless, but damn, it's cool seeing Shadow being a good guy. Too bad Shadow isn't really used anymore. I can't help but be amused that there's far more bad points than good about the game, but the creator is hesitant to outright call it bad because they think Shadow is just that cool. Goes to show just how important style and aesthetic is for Sonic.