Are we making too many of these threads? Yes, we are. Do I care? No, I don't. Sonic and the Black Knight is a flawed masterpiece. It's so much fun. Sonic is fast. Shadow can use Chaos Control. Knuckles can glide. You can play as Blaze. The environments are varied. There is no Green Hill. It is just darn beautiful. The soundtrack is awesome. Sure, the swordplay is a tad unresponsive and it's a bit short, but those are minor issues in my opinion (and in regards to length there are a TON of missions to add replay value). Sonic and the Black Knight needs more love.