Sonic and Sega Retro Message Board: Witch Chao - Viewing Profile - Sonic and Sega Retro Message Board

Hey, thanks again! I see what you're saying there. I didn't like the face on my old one either.
Now Here's comparison of all versions, inlucindg PC2's face revision, and one of my own that I didn't get a chance to thrwo up yet:

I think that PC2's face revision is the best, and I may go with it, I'll just have to give a pixel back to her torso(I shortened her torso in my Rev. B, and then used the same body.) I also changed the pose because this new one gives it a more innocent flare while maiking it easier to work with. I also shrank her right foot by a pixel, so it looks less akward.

Now I'm stuck though. Should we use the CD Pink, or this new Pink that I came up with?
Also, should I give a pixel back to her torso on the PC2 rev. B?

P.S. Thanks again PC2. You found a core problem underlying Amy's bleeding hues and strange growth spurt. Maybe that's why it looked really unprofessional...

Thanks for elaborating guys. I made some changes to her today. I may make even more:

Compare old to new.
The biggest problems seem to be the size and colors. I know she's not taller than Sonic, but it was a start :p. I shrank her by about 2 pixels (Making her skirt look tremendoulsy better). She's now as tall as Sonic 3's Sonic. I may be able to get away with chopping another couple pixels of her torso, but thats about as small as she's getting.
I used the pink shades I hade and shaded the head a little more, and added some colors and some more shading to her shoes and skirt.

And Jayextee's thing about Amy's pink strikes as interesting. I'm definatly not using Sonic CD"s Amy pink, but I'll look into fixing that up. Without even reading most of the new comments though, it looks like I'm improving.

What's left seems to be fixing up the pink, maybe shrinking her again, fixing up her face area(Her eyes don't look "cute" enough to me and the mouth still looks weird.), and possibly giving Amy a new outfit(mabye not the SA, but something that may be more fashionable than a green polo on an orange tutu XP)

And here I thought I was using too many.. =P Where do you think I should add more shading/highlights?

In Sonic CD, she's barely Sonic's hieght, and in all of her other appearneces pre-SA, she's roughly about Sonic's size. Since I don't know what Sonic we're using yet(Maybe the ones on the previous page?), there's no real appropriate way to scale her correctly right now.

It's okay for the critique. I was actually waiting for it =P, so I can fix whats wrong. By the way, what exactly do you mean be "professional"? Just the issues descirbed, or as a rate of the overall job?

A couple of Amys I put together. I really like the outcome, but I believes it's your guys' opinions that count is it not?
Anyway, I know that even though we never decided weather she'd actually be in the game, I know for sure it'll most likely be just a cameo role or a damsel-in-distress role, since no-one around here seems to like her enough to warrant anything bigger than that, weather it be her 1993 incarnation or her 1999 one. Anyways, I like her, and I like the sprites, and I should probably stop pratling so you'll pay attention to the image instead of the text this time

Well, since 'Sunset' seems to be one decide theme, the color orange(and subsequently shades of it and yellow) would go along with it.
I use Citrus to describe color, not fruit or imply that it somehow has anything to do with oranges or lemons.