[Aquaslash]

87th, on May 30 2007, 11:56 AM, said:

Although the sprites themselves look nice, there's quite a jump between the second-last and last sprites, so the movement might look quite jerky when animated.

It actually works out because it goes by really fast.

[Aquaslash]

Ok, palette dilemma time.

I'm getting plenty of comments about one or the other so I'm looking for a mass opinion of which of these two Silver palettes look better:

[Chimpo]

One on the left, but just a slight bit brighter.

[Flygon]

I honestly think that pallet 1 is better, why? It looks better on the eyes in my opinion.

This post has been edited by flygon: 05 June 2007 - 03:57 AM

[nineko]

Right one. Silver is silver, not PINK.

[Bowser]

The one on the left seems more "fitting", IMO. You can see the shading a bit more clearly, and.. well, it just looks better. :P Though I wouldn't automatically jump to saying that the right one hurts my eyes, because in reality, A. It doesn't really, and B. Both sprites are infront of that turquoise-ish background, which may be why I don't see the one on the right all that good. Though they both look pretty nest, for now, I'll go with the left.

[Tweaker]

One on the right has a more fitting color scheme, more like Silver in Sonic Next and etc.

[SMTP]

The right, but even then it still needs to be more white... :P

[Dark Sonic]

I'd go with a brighter version of the one on the left. The right one looks like it's turquoise or something.

[87th]

I think the image can be a little deceiving. The background colour, alongside the various images around it (signatures, avatars, etc.) made me think that the left sprite was kind of pink. I opened the file in Paint, changed the background to white and magnified it. After doing that, I felt that the left sprite looked far better.

[Aquaslash]

[Upthorn]

Now that I see them blown up, I'm reversing the decision I made in IRC last night. The sprite on the right is way too green.

[Hivebrain]

There's a Firefox extension that lets you enlarge images, btw. I find it very useful for looking at screenshots and sprites. Image Zoom, it's called.

[Rockman Zero]

The one on the right looks better. It's more silver. =P

[Shadow Fire]

From what images I've seen of the actual Silver, I'd say the left sprite is best.