[Thundertimi]

No death egg again...
It's ok if you repeat it once, but 3rd time is stupidity.
I think robotnik learned his lesson :P

Nack should be miniboss of each act 1.

[Mobiethian]

I think Nack and Amy Rose should both be in this game somewhere. Just my opinion.

[Polygon Jim]

I don't really think Amy should be in it, if she's anything more than a cameo. She's nothing like the 3 main characters, they all are based off Sonic, but with some differences. Tails just has the extra ability to be able to fly, Knuckles can glide, and climb walls. Besides that, they are all just Sonic with different art.


Amy on the other hand is nothing like any of them, except for looking like a pink Sonic with clothes.

This post has been edited by Polygon Jim: 11 November 2008 - 03:37 PM

[Thundertimi]

BJCharles, on Nov 11 2008, 03:24 PM, said:

I think Nack and Amy Rose should both be in this game somewhere. Just my opinion.

Hell no!

Amy was one of biggest reason, why I don't like 3d sonic games or sonic cd
(It does not bother me in sonic cd so much, but still)

If I see amy in this game, I'll kill myself.

Anyway...

I think, Nack is good idea.

[Mobiethian]

Thundertimi, on Nov 11 2008, 03:50 PM, said:

BJCharles, on Nov 11 2008, 03:24 PM, said:

I think Nack and Amy Rose should both be in this game somewhere. Just my opinion.

Hell no!

Amy was one of biggest reason, why I don't like 3d sonic games or sonic cd
(It does not bother me in sonic cd so much, but still)

If I see amy in this game, I'll kill myself.

Anyway...

I think, Nack is good idea.

While we're at it, I think we'll throw in Cream and Big... lol nah, just kidding.. But seriously, it is very unlikely that Amy Rose will be a part of this due to the feedback against it. However, I strongly believe that a 16 bit Nack would be a whole new and exciting thing.

[Super]

Needs moar unlockable Nack mode, ala Megaman Maverick Hunter X, where you could play as Vile. He needs to play like a Gunstar. FACT.

No, Just kinda ramblin' there, as epic as it would be. Also, I suggest an option to change the name from Nack to Fang, to appease all groups.

[Mobiethian]

Super, on Nov 11 2008, 04:20 PM, said:

Needs moar unlockable Nack mode, ala Megaman Maverick Hunter X, where you could play as Vile. He needs to play like a Gunstar. FACT.

No, Just kinda ramblin' there, as epic as it would be. Also, I suggest an option to change the name from Nack to Fang, to appease all groups.

I think Fang the Sniper sounds better than Nack the Weasel.

[synchronizer]

It's like Miles "Tails" Prower. I agree with the inclusion of Fang, because it could finally be his time to shine as a bad guy, but Amy just would seem a bit out of place.

This post has been edited by synchronizer: 11 November 2008 - 05:12 PM

[muteKi]

Playable Fang is a great idea, I'm just unsure how it would be pulled off, like how he would control.




I kinda would like Amy too, though...

[Xeric]

synchronizer, on Nov 11 2008, 10:11 PM, said:

It's like Miles "Tails" Prower. I agree with the inclusion of Fang, because it could finally be his time to shine as a bad guy, but Amy just would seem a bit out of place.

How would she be out of place? After SCD, she was pretty much obsessed with Sonic. From what I can comprehend, the only reason she wasn't in S3 was because it was on Angel Island, and how would she get their? Especially since she didn't have any interaction with Tails until Sonic Adventure. :/ (Just talking crap here D:)

Whatever though. I still think Amy should be included some how. If not playable, defiantly cameo. Perhaps she could be kidnapped by Metal Sonic again..

[synchronizer]

I do think a cameo would be good for Amy, and I would like to see Metal Sonic in there too. The Sonic CD or Chaotix styled Metal Sonic that is.

[SoNick]

Thundertimi, on Nov 11 2008, 02:50 PM, said:

BJCharles, on Nov 11 2008, 03:24 PM, said:

I think Nack and Amy Rose should both be in this game somewhere. Just my opinion.

Hell no!

Amy was one of biggest reason, why I don't like 3d sonic games or sonic cd
(It does not bother me in sonic cd so much, but still)

If I see amy in this game, I'll kill myself.

Such an articulate argument for why she should not be in the game!


I like Super's idea of having Fang/Nack unlockable, Maverick Hunter X style.

[Matwek]

Thundertimi, on Nov 11 2008, 08:12 PM, said:

No death egg again...
It's ok if you repeat it once, but 3rd time is stupidity.
I think robotnik learned his lesson :P

Nack should be miniboss of each act 1.

It doesn't necessarily have to be a Death Egg, could be an airship or something. Besides the main aim was come up with an idea thats both origonal and in keeping with the sonic style of story and having split paths with sonic going into space like normal and knuckles taking the fight underground for a change seems like a good start to coming up with a story that covers both.

[Thundertimi]

Airship sounds good to me.

[Matwek]

Robotnik builds flying fotress containing an army of classic Metal Sonics, needs Master Emerald to build bomb so hires Nack to steal it in exchange for his own custom Metal Sonic.
Sonics story involves him going after Robotnik before he builds his bomb, Knuckles' story has him chasing down Nack before he can steal the Master Emerald.

That way we can keep similar levels but have the bosses for each character being different, covers both people wanting classic Metal Sonic as well as a new one, New character in the form of Nack, might not be playable but he'll be more involved with the plot then the Egg Bro thing of SK and a story that doesn't involve the Death Egg that can be summed up in two sentences (like all classic sonic stories).
Ideas, comments, suggestions?

Bit of a collage I did when bored to make things more visual (pictures taken from some comics).