Which version of the Panic Puppet Act 1 song do you like the most?

Saturn version =P

 

Overall the Saturn version was a much better port. But I'm actually going to have to go with the Genesis' music for this level.

 

I am actually split, I like Act 2 Genesis, and Act 1 Saturn/PC vers.

 

Can an admin give me back the chance to vote? I clicked on "null vote" when the poll was still broken, and now that the poll is fixed I can't vote

 

Dreamcast version :D

 

I like them both. I don't really have a "favorite" out of the two choices.

 

It seems that I can't vote. Oh well, Genesis +1.

 

I Never played the saturn version at all, so I'll go with Genesis, though I liked the final robotnik boss battle more.

 

The Genesis version wins. I haven't played the Saturn version.

-Nick O.

 

I'm tied between Act 1 Saturn and Act 2 Genesis. However, keeping only t0o Act 1, Saturn wins. Act 1 Genesis is still cool though.

 

I voted for the Genesis version. Unfortunately, I haven't heard the Saturn version, so my decision is bias.

Boy, it seems like it could end up in a split win for both versions.

 

I was going to make a snarky "The one before act 1" statement, but fakkit. Saturn.

 

I've listened to the soundtrack of the Saturn version of Sonic 3D Blast a few months ago, and I wasn't very impressed with it. My vote goes to the Genesis version.

 

I personally liked Act 2 in the Genesis version, and act 1 in the other versions of Sonic 3D blast personally.

 

Jun Senoue got fucking owned by Richard Jacques. Poll over. Saturn soundtrack for the win.

 

That bgm in the genesis version kicks the crap out of the saturn version's one, IMO.

 

Well...

Otherwise, it doesn't change anything. The Saturn version shows a lot of good influences (Seal, Enigma, etc.), a very good use of synths of the time and well driven and inspired melodies. Okay, they tend to repeat themselves through the song but the way Richard Jacques managed himself to use different arrangements saved it all.

On the other hand, the Genesis version shows good melodies, in almost the same style as Jacques', a really good use of the FM chip (those kind of sounds you'd love to have on your DX, but I prefer Chaotix sounds personally) but sounds a bit less inspired melodically.

So, conclusion... R. Jacques wins for me.

BTW, the act 2 theme shares exactly the same influences as act 1 musically (though more Enigma-imitated) even if it's not as sophisticated. But that lush pad all over the song still have its effect on me. Dunno why.

Of course, if you're not an electropop enthusiast, you can't understand. :P

 

Perhaps, Dioxas, but

Anyway, personally I think the Genesis version is better because there's more of a proper melody.

 

lol, I mistook the song. XDDD (how the hell have I been able to make such a fixation on RRZ?)
But I didn't made that "review" for nothing. It just shows how good Richard Jacques worked on that game soundtrack.

Well, I still prefer Jacques' version, even if it might sound too "technoish". It might fit more to the level. Senoue's version is for once more melodic and covers and electronic style. Might be one of his best tune out of that game but... my love for dance music makes me prefer Jacques' version. XDD

And, oh, a last note: if I'm mistaking music zones so much, it's because I never went really deep on that game. Sorry if looked like a jerk at that moment.

EDIT: dunno how many times I edited that post lol (yeah, I was still mistaking it with another zone... Green Grove)